Friday, September 21, 2007

NCERT and Evaluation Criteria

Concerned over increasing number of suicides among students, the NCERT, a central apex body, has suggested to schools across the country to replace the word fail with unsatisfactory or repeat.Do you think that this is a right move?
Guy_on_black_YBX says: said...
LOL, so they think people are so dumb that they wont understand if they have passed or failed? Why not pass all of them even if they have scored a "0" did they suggest any replacements?

Lp53 said...
Our famers fail: suicide Our students fail: suicide Our babus and netas fail: they repeat...:D

Busybee said...
meaning less change.

nz said...
right move ??? How can someone be so stupid to even suggest that changing the word would help cutting down the suicides among students ?? Even my 6 yr old would know that its one and the same thing.

Abx said...
no right or wrong......... only satisfactory or unsatisfactory

Savy said...
i think so..fail means you are no good and repeat def means you are good fr another chance..fail has serious repurcussions tagged to it..the wprd repeat gives one hope...a try again at leeast..I fam all for it.

VS said...
Reminded me of our great PM. Ms I. Gandhi. Got every body over the poverty line by abolishing III class in the railways. No Indian travelled III class, only I or II. Sad, the main issues never get addresed.

Frenchita said...
yes it is .. well ..the word "repeat " sounds worse the word .. "unsatisfatory " may be suggested and implemented .. like vs says ..the real issues are not being addressed probably out of range for NCERT huh ? :)

Tejbir said...
ironical - so at last the teachers accept that they don't teach common sense to their students!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (aren't they being naive to believe that students won't be able to make out the difference?)

Wise donkee said...
yes. atleast one doesnt think of oneself as a failure. but the problem is not just what one thinks, but the expectations of parents. unless parents behave differently, we cant expect a big difference in the suicide rate. parents and teachers must encourage and not discourage children who dont score the required marks..

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

LOL, so they think people are so dumb that they wont understand if they have passed or failed? Why not pass all of them even if they have scored a "0"
did they suggest any replacements?

Anonymous said...

Our famers fail: suicide
Our students fail: suicide
Our babus and netas fail: they repeat...:D

Anonymous said...

meaning less change.

Anonymous said...

right move ??? How can someone be so stupid to even suggest that changing the word would help cutting down the suicides among students ?? Even my 6 yr old would know that its one and the same thing.

Anonymous said...

no right or wrong.........
only satisfactory or unsatisfactory

Anonymous said...

i think so..fail means you are no good and repeat def means you are good fr another chance..fail has serious repurcussions tagged to it..the wprd repeat gives one hope...a try again at leeast..I fam all for it.

Anonymous said...

Reminded me of our great PM. Ms I. Gandhi.
Got every body over the poverty line by abolishing III class in the railways.
No Indian travelled III class, only I or II.

Sad, the main issues never get addresed.

Anonymous said...

yes it is ..
well ..the word "repeat " sounds worse
the word .. "unsatisfatory " may be suggested and implemented ..
like vs says ..the real issues are not being addressed
probably out of range for NCERT huh ? :)

Anonymous said...

ironical - so at last the teachers accept that they don't teach
common sense to their students!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
(aren't they being naive to believe that
students won't be able to make out the difference?)

Anonymous said...

yes. atleast one doesnt think of oneself as a failure. but the problem is not just what one thinks, but the expectations of parents.
unless parents behave differently, we cant expect a big difference in the suicide rate.
parents and teachers must encourage and not discourage children who dont score the required marks..