GussaWaala said…
Military is needed in Kashmir to protect the borders. No one in Kashmir has the right to prevent that. Army policing the streets of Kashmir? Yes, and for several reasons. Its not the job of Army, it really hasnt helped. terrorism is still rampant. So why not try a new startegy.
Hot Shayaris said…
Military is of course required... what's gone wrong into the heads of these PDP's?I think PDP's gone mad.. how come they are considering removal of ARMY from JAMMU & KASHMIR?????
nz said…
They are obviously not very smart to even suggest such a thing !
lostpatrol53 said…
Q1: Who is PDP? A1: Senior partner in ruling alliance, led by Syed Mufti and his daughter Mehbooba Mufti, X-INC politicians. Q2: Who captured Mehabooba once and how was she freed? A2: The Kasmiri feedom fighters kidnapped her. Delhi bartered thier companions in its jail to free Mehbooba. Q3: Why did she not persuade them to release her unconditionally? Were they Sheik Abdulla's men who kidnapped her? A3: Once she needed army to help her end the Abdulla dynasty. Now, her politics has changed. She wants the separatists on her side. Because the abdullas have gone over to teh NDP side. Q4: What shall we do? Withdraw the Army? to where? To the borders, forward mobilization? A4: Yes, let us withdraw the army from the streets. Let them go back to barracks and border posts. If 700,000 men were to be stationed at forward posts on border, Musharraf might squeel. His Sino and Yankee godfathers will be told hwo can he fight terror on his western flank when the Indian Army is breathing down his neck on eastern flank. Q5: What is the alternative? A5: Simple. Appoint Mehabooba Mufti to Indian Cabinet and make her the Defence Minister. The Army will be withdrawn. Private armies of Abdulla, Dar, Lone, Shah, Patel, Mufti, Azad and such 370 outfits will kill each other and Kashmir people will be finally free of terrorist's Ak-47.
frenchita said…
No its not ... do not remove the military... not ..but add more ..seal off the border completely so the ISI agents dont cross . as you catch the Kashmiri terrorists who deserve no trial, ...exterminate them for the vermin they are ...
tejbir said…
as for the question... i am a kashmiri though born and brought up in Delhi but i've been going here almost every year till a decade back as many relatives lived there, so i might be reflecting the feeling of a kashmiri & not of a muslim or a hindu Yes, the army must be taken away! It will be a tough decision but it needs to be supported by some strong measures like good opportunities for the kashmiri youth opportunities for earning/doing business/getting education and here i want my country to do what our Father of the nation would have done - continue the growth measures for the state and the people and win them over agreed it will take time and pain, but that is the only solution and to counter army withdrawal, give some additional powers to police and make sure we deploy police personnel who are above any doubt and have shown exemplary integrity
DecentmonKey said…
Of course not ! Army should be stationed at every border of the country and in more numbers at J&K border !
7 comments:
Military is needed in Kashmir to protect the borders. No one in Kashmir has the right to prevent that. Army policing the streets of Kashmir? Yes, and for several reasons. Its not the job of Army, it really hasnt helped. terrorism is still rampant. So why not try a new startegy.
Military is of course required... what's gone wrong into the heads of these PDP's?I think PDP's gone mad.. how come they are considering removal of ARMY from JAMMU & KASHMIR?????
They are obviously not very smart to even suggest such a thing !
Dear Shrawan,
Q1: Who is PDP?
A1: Senior partner in ruling alliance, led by Syed Mufti and his daughter Mehbooba Mufti, X-INC politicians.
Q2: Who captured Mehabooba once and how was she freed?
A2: The Kasmiri feedom fighters kidnapped her. Delhi bartered thier companions in its jail to free Mehbooba.
Q3: Why did she not persuade them to release her unconditionally? Were they Sheik Abdulla's men who kidnapped her?
A3: Once she needed army to help her end the Abdulla dynasty. Now, her politics has changed. She wants the separatists on her side. Because the abdullas have gone over to teh NDP side.
Q4: What shall we do? Withdraw the Army? to where? To the borders, forward mobilization?
A4: Yes, let us withdraw the army from the streets. Let them go back to barracks and border posts. If 700,000 men were to be stationed at forward posts on border, Musharraf might squeel. His Sino and Yankee godfathers will be told hwo can he fight terror on his western flank when the Indian Army is breathing down his neck on eastern flank.
Q5: What is the alternative?
A5: Simple. Appoint Mehabooba Mufti to Indian Cabinet and make her the Defence Minister. The Army will be withdrawn. Private armies of Abdulla, Dar, Lone, Shah, Patel, Mufti, Azad and such 370 outfits will kill each other and Kashmir people will be finally free of terrorist's Ak-47.
No its not ...
do not remove the military... not ..but add more ..seal off the border completely so the ISI agents dont cross .
as you catch the Kashmiri terrorists who deserve no trial, ...exterminate them for the vermin they are ...
Shrawan bro!
kaisa hai?
as for the question...
i am a kashmiri though born and brought up in Delhi
but i've been going here almost every year till a decade back
as many relatives lived there, so i might be reflecting
the feeling of a kashmiri & not of a muslim or a hindu
Yes, the army must be taken away!
It will be a tough decision but it needs to be supported by
some strong measures like good opportunities for the kashmiri youth
opportunities for earning/doing business/getting education
and here i want my country to do what our Father of the nation
would have done - continue the growth measures for the state
and the people and win them over
agreed it will take time and pain, but that is the only solution
and to counter army withdrawal, give some additional powers to
police and make sure we deploy police personnel who are
above any doubt and have shown exemplary integrity
Of course not !
Army should be stationed at every border of the country and in more numbers at J&K border !
Post a Comment