Government is planning to make it mandatory that only women judges will hear rape cases.Do you think that it will help rape victims?
Busybee said...
YES, it will. It could make for faster justice, and also easier for the victims to depose before the judge.
Vrij said...
It surely is not gonna have too much implication, except that, as BB says, it'll b easier on the victims.. but how much? The main interrogaters the police n most advocates r still male..
Gul said...
Bahut hi sahi pahal hai.Bilkul sahi hona yese hi chahiye kyukee jitna ek Aurat hone ke naate case ki gambhirtaa ko samza aur jaana ja sakta hai vo ek Man Judge ke thoda kathinkar hai. Ek sahraaniy pahal hai.
Pri said...
well i think it wil surely help to some extent..will save ebbarrassment on the victims part...and a woman judge will also hav a better understanding of the case and wil be able to stop the opposition frm harassing the victim(well i belive she should do tht).
Rajesh (Kachra King) said...
It would help to an extent .. I would say that only women prosecuters should be allowed too ... but then they might get a little biased at times ..
frenchita said...
Yes , women judges will help rape victims . They are more understanding whereas Indian men are chauvenistic and tend to blame the victim , although some men are stricter with the rapist .
DecentmonKey said...
Yes, it will help the genuine rape victims..
Ashiya said...
i am not too sure if it would be too helpful..... i think its more about our thinking... and how we treat the victims... its about fair, timely and correct judegement... be the judge be Man or a women..... please give justice to a victim on time......
surabhi said...
maybe it will help....but only to a certain extent!!i really dnt thnk it wud make dat much of a difference!!
Z-girl said...
Women judges may be more sensitive to the issue and make it easier for the victim. But there are prosecutors and others present who might be male. But is there any data that shows that male judges have been ineffective? I doubt it. There are flawed laws that need to be re-written. The whole process of ensuring justice should not be delayed further if there are no women judges available.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
10 comments:
YES, it will. It could make for faster justice, and also easier for the victims to depose before the judge.
It surely is not gonna have too much implication, except that, as BB says, it'll b easier on the victims.. but how much? The main interrogaters the police n most advocates r still male..
Hi shrawan ji...!
Bahut hi sahi pahal hai.Bilkul sahi hona yese hi chahiye kyukee jitna ek Aurat hone ke naate case ki gambhirtaa ko samza aur jaana ja sakta hai vo ek Man Judge ke thoda kathinkar hai. Ek sahraaniy pahal hai.
well i think it wil surely help to some extent..will save ebbarrassment on the victims part...and a woman judge will also hav a better understanding of the case and wil be able to stop the opposition frm harassing the victim(well i belive she should do tht).
pri
It would help to an extent .. I would say that only women prosecuters should be allowed too ... but then they might get a little biased at times ..
Yes , women judges will help rape victims . They are more understanding whereas Indian men are chauvenistic and tend to blame the victim , although some men are stricter with the rapist .
Yes, it will help the genuine rape victims..
hey shrawan... i am not too sure if it would be too helpful..... i think its more about our thinking... and how we treat the victims... its about fair, timely and correct judegement... be the judge be Man or a women..... please give justice to a victim on time......
maybe it will help....but only to a certain extent!!i really dnt thnk it wud make dat much of a difference!!
Women judges may be more sensitive to the issue and make it easier for the victim. But there are prosecutors and others present who might be male. But is there any data that shows that male judges have been ineffective? I doubt it.
There are flawed laws that need to be re-written. The whole process of ensuring justice should not be delayed further if there are no women judges available.
Post a Comment